Company Payment Phone Numbers

A Central Insurance Company..............................888-234-6926
Adirondack Insurance Exchange.........................888.517.8360
Allegany Co-Op Insurance Co................................800-333-1679
Foremost Insurance Company..............................800-532-4221
GMAC Insurance Company.....................................877-468-3466
The Hartford...............................................................800-962-3170
.......................................................................................866-467-8730 Check or credit card
Merchants Insurance Group..................................800-462-8182
Mercury.......................................................................800-503-3724
MetLife........................................................................800-680-3354
NY Central Mutual Fire Insurance Co...................800-355-5220
Peerless Insurance Company...............................800-228-7830 Check or credit card
.......................................................................................877-659-0101 One-time EFT
......................................................................................877-659-0096 EFT Enrollment
Philadelphia Insurance Companies.....................877-438-7459
Progressive Casualty Insurance Co....................800-875-5581
SafeCo Insurance.....................................................877-566-6001 (Option 3)
Tower Group Companies........................................877-883-6599
Travelers.....................................................................800-550-7716 Personal
.......................................................................................877-878-2468 Personal credit card
.......................................................................................800-252-2268 Commercial
Travelers Flood Insurance Program....................800-356-6670
Zurich Insurance Services.....................................800-332-6641